Skip to investigation
VValidation Detective™
Case 017 · Price ValidationEvidence Investigation LiveExit Lab
Exhibit 1 of 4
Can the business conclude that customers will pay $49 per month?

Classify each exhibit by what it actually proves—not by how impressive the number sounds.

Survey

Interest survey

83% of 146 respondents said they would “probably” or “definitely” use the service at $49/month.

CLASSIFICATION REVIEW

What it does not prove

Best next test

Case closed · Investigation dossier

The evidence supports interest—and something stronger.

The case becomes defensible only when the strongest behavior is separated from weaker expressions of intent.

Strongest evidence
Paid preorders

Actual payment at the target price is materially stronger than stated interest.

Weakest inference
Survey intent = demand

Stated willingness can help frame a test, but it cannot substitute for committed behavior.

Still unknown
Retention at $49/month

Initial payment does not prove ongoing usage, renewal or profitable service delivery.

Best next test
Run a small paid cohort

Measure activation, usage, renewal and delivery economics with real customers.

Enter Decision Lab
Case 017 · Evidence Investigation

The $49 Question

A founder believes customers will pay $49 each month. Four pieces of evidence look encouraging. Your job is to separate what the business hopes from what the evidence actually supports.

Your roleEvidence analyst
ClaimCustomers will pay $49/mo
Exhibits4 evidence objects
ObjectiveClose with a defensible conclusion
Back to Resources